Civil Litigation: Define and Understand the Legal Process

by

Civil Litigation: What is it?

When people or companies disagree, they sometimes need a formal process to resolve their differences. That’s where civil litigation comes in.

Civil litigation is a way to settle disputes between people, businesses, or other organizations. Unlike criminal cases, civil litigation isn’t about punishing someone. It’s about finding a fair resolution, usually through a court decision or an agreed-upon settlement.

What kinds of disputes fall under the umbrella of civil litigation? Almost any kind you can think of:

  • Disagreements about contracts
  • Property disputes
  • Personal injury claims
  • Workplace disagreements
  • Divorces and custody battles
  • Intellectual property

This article will provide a comprehensive overview of civil litigation, explain the key steps and procedures involved, and highlight the differences between civil and common law systems as they relate to civil litigation.

Key Elements of Civil Litigation

Let’s break down some of the essential pieces of a civil lawsuit.

Parties Involved

In every civil case, you’ll find two main players:

  • Plaintiff: This is the person or entity who starts the lawsuit. They’re the ones claiming they’ve been wronged and are seeking some kind of compensation or remedy.
  • Defendant: This is the person or entity being sued. They have to respond to the plaintiff’s claims and defend their actions (or inactions).

Types of Disputes

Civil litigation covers a huge range of conflicts. Here are some of the most common types:

  • Contract Disputes: These happen when someone breaks the terms of an agreement. Maybe they didn’t pay up, didn’t do what they promised, or lied about something important.
  • Property Disputes: These involve disagreements over land, buildings, or personal belongings. Think arguments about property lines, who owns what, or problems between landlords and tenants.
  • Personal Injury Claims: These cases pop up when someone gets hurt, either physically or emotionally, because of someone else’s carelessness or intentional actions. Car crashes, slip-and-fall accidents, and medical mistakes fall into this category.
  • Employment Disputes: These are disagreements between bosses and employees. They can involve getting fired for the wrong reasons, facing discrimination, or dealing with harassment.
  • Family Law Disputes: These cover legal issues related to marriage, divorce, who gets the kids, and who pays support.
  • Intellectual Property Disputes: These cases involve things like patents (inventions), trademarks (logos and brand names), copyrights (artistic works), and trade secrets (confidential business information).

As you can see, civil litigation touches on many different aspects of our lives and business dealings.

The Civil Litigation Process: A Step-by-Step Guide

So, how does a civil lawsuit actually work? Buckle up, because it can be a long and winding road. Here’s a breakdown of the typical steps:

Filing a Lawsuit

  1. Commencement of Action: The whole thing starts when the plaintiff (the person who’s been wronged) files a complaint with the court. This complaint is basically a written story outlining what happened, why they think the defendant (the person who did the wronging) is responsible, and what they want as compensation.
  2. Selecting a Forum: You can’t just file a lawsuit anywhere. You have to pick the right court. This involves figuring out if the court has jurisdiction (the power to hear the case) and if the venue (the location of the court) is appropriate. It’s like choosing the right battlefield.

Response to the Lawsuit

  1. Service of Process: Once the lawsuit is filed, the defendant needs to be officially notified. This is done through “service of process,” which means they get a copy of the complaint and a summons (a notice to appear in court). How this is done varies a LOT depending on where the defendant is located.
  2. Defendant’s Answer: The defendant then has a limited time to file an answer to the complaint. In this answer, they admit or deny the plaintiff’s claims. If they don’t respond at all, the plaintiff can get a default judgment, meaning they automatically win. Ouch!

Discovery

  1. Purpose of Discovery: This is where things get interesting. Discovery is all about gathering information and evidence related to the case. It’s like a legal scavenger hunt. The goal is to prepare for trial (or, more often, settlement negotiations).
  2. Methods of Discovery: There are several ways to uncover information:
    • Interrogatories: Written questions that one side sends to the other. Think of it as a legal questionnaire.
    • Depositions: Oral examinations of witnesses under oath. It’s like a pre-trial interview, but with a court reporter taking notes.
    • Document Requests: Requests to hand over documents, emails, photos, you name it. If it’s relevant, it’s fair game.
    • Requests for Admission: Requests to admit or deny specific facts. This can help narrow down the issues in dispute.

Pre-Trial Motions

  1. Purpose of Pre-Trial Motions: Before the trial actually starts, lawyers can file motions to try to resolve legal issues or limit what can be presented at trial.
  2. Types of Pre-Trial Motions:
    • Motion to Dismiss: This asks the court to throw the case out, usually because the court doesn’t have jurisdiction or because the plaintiff’s complaint doesn’t state a valid claim.
    • Motion for Summary Judgment: This asks the court to rule in favor of one side without a trial, arguing that there are no genuine issues of material fact and that the law clearly favors one party.

Trial and Judgment

If a settlement can’t be reached, the case proceeds to trial. Here’s what you can expect.

Trial Procedures

There are two main types of trials:

  • Bench trial: In a bench trial, there’s no jury. The judge hears the evidence and decides the case.
  • Jury trial: In a jury trial, a panel of citizens listens to the evidence and decides the facts. The judge still oversees the legal aspects of the trial.

During the trial, both sides get to present evidence to support their side of the story. This can include:

  • Witness testimony (people answering questions under oath)
  • Documents (contracts, emails, letters, etc.)
  • Physical evidence (objects relevant to the case)

The rules of evidence govern what evidence can be admitted at trial. These rules are in place to ensure fairness and that only reliable information is considered.

Judgment

After all the evidence is presented, the judge or jury makes a decision. This decision can be in favor of the plaintiff (the person who filed the lawsuit) or the defendant (the person being sued).

There are different types of judgments a court can issue:

  • Monetary judgment: This means the court orders the defendant to pay the plaintiff a certain amount of money as compensation for their losses.
  • Injunctive relief: This is a court order telling the defendant to do something specific or to stop doing something. For example, a court might order a company to stop infringing on a patent.

If the plaintiff wins and gets a judgment, they still have to collect the money. This can involve:

  • Garnishing the defendant’s wages (taking a portion of their paycheck)
  • Seizing the defendant’s assets (like bank accounts or property)
  • Putting a lien on the defendant’s property (which means they can’t sell it until the debt is paid)

Post-Trial Motions and Appeals

Even when a trial ends, the legal process might not be over. The losing party has options for challenging the outcome.

Post-Trial Motions

After a verdict is reached, the losing party can file post-trial motions. These motions ask the court to reconsider its decision, often arguing that errors occurred during the trial or that the verdict was not supported by the evidence.

Some common post-trial motions include:

  • Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding the Verdict (JNOV): This motion argues that no reasonable jury could have reached the verdict based on the evidence presented. It asks the judge to overturn the jury’s decision.
  • Motion for a New Trial: This motion asks the court to order a new trial, typically because of errors that occurred during the original trial, such as improper admission of evidence or incorrect jury instructions.

Appeals

If a party is unhappy with the trial court’s final judgment (even after post-trial motions), they usually have the right to appeal the decision to a higher court.

During an appeal, the appellate court reviews the record of the trial court proceedings to determine whether any legal errors occurred that might have affected the outcome of the case. It’s worth noting that appellate review processes can differ; some civil-law systems may allow for more flexibility in considering new evidence during the appeal.

The appellate court can make one of several decisions: affirm (uphold) the trial court’s judgment, reverse (overturn) the trial court’s judgment, or modify the trial court’s judgment.

Civil vs. Common Law Systems: Key Differences in Civil Litigation

It’s worth noting that the way civil litigation is handled can vary greatly depending on whether a country operates under a civil law system or a common law system. Here are some key differences:

Pre-Trial Procedures

In the lead-up to a trial, both systems have procedures for gathering information and narrowing the issues in dispute.

Discovery

Common-law systems like the United States and England generally have extensive “discovery” procedures, allowing parties to request documents, answer written questions, and give sworn testimony before trial. Civil-law systems tend to have less developed discovery processes.

Motion Practice

Pretrial motion practice, where lawyers ask the court to make rulings on legal issues before trial, is also more common and extensive in common-law systems.

Trial Procedures

The trial itself also looks different depending on the legal system.

Role of the Judge

In civil-law systems, judges often take a more active role in gathering evidence and questioning witnesses. In common-law systems, judges primarily act as referees, ensuring that lawyers follow the rules of evidence and procedure.

Use of Juries

Jury trials are more common in common-law systems, especially in the United States. Civil-law systems often rely on judges or panels of judges (sometimes including “lay assessors” who are not lawyers) to decide cases.

Appeals Process

Even the appeals process differs between the two systems.

Scope of Review

Civil-law systems may allow appellate courts more flexibility to consider new evidence on appeal. Common-law systems typically focus on reviewing whether the trial court made any errors of law.

Frequently Asked Questions

What governs civil litigation?

Civil litigation is primarily governed by a complex interplay of federal and state laws, rules of procedure, and established legal precedents. At the federal level, the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure dictate how lawsuits are conducted in federal courts, covering everything from filing a complaint to conducting discovery and presenting evidence at trial. Each state also has its own set of civil procedure rules that govern lawsuits within that state’s court system. Beyond these procedural rules, substantive laws—whether statutory or based on common law principles—define the rights and obligations of parties involved in a dispute. Court decisions and interpretations of these laws create precedents that guide future litigation.

What is the difference between general litigation and civil litigation?

The terms “general litigation” and “civil litigation” are often used interchangeably, but there’s a subtle distinction. “Civil litigation” refers specifically to legal disputes between individuals, organizations, or entities seeking monetary damages or specific performance, rather than criminal penalties. It encompasses a wide range of cases, including contract disputes, personal injury claims, property disputes, and intellectual property litigation. “General litigation,” while broader, can technically include both civil and criminal cases. However, in practice, “general litigation” is frequently used as a catch-all term to describe a law firm or attorney’s practice that handles a variety of civil litigation matters rather than specializing in a specific area.

In conclusion

Civil litigation is a critical process for resolving disputes and upholding the rule of law. Whether you’re directly involved in a legal dispute or simply affected by one, it’s important to understand how civil litigation works.

If you find yourself in a dispute that could lead to litigation, it’s essential to seek advice from a qualified attorney or lawyer. A legal professional can help you understand your rights and responsibilities and guide you through the legal process.

Looking ahead, alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods are becoming increasingly popular as a way to resolve conflicts outside of the traditional courtroom setting. These methods can often be more efficient and cost-effective than traditional litigation.

Because civil litigation processes are constantly evolving and adapting across different legal systems, comparative legal studies are increasingly important for understanding the nuances of dispute resolution in a globalized world.